Let's talk about burgers & hot dogs in Brooklyn

1) Allswell

This laidback Williamsburg tavern serves sustainably sourced food that is yummy, creative and always excellent. They offer four different burgers: the Classic Allswell Burger, the Portobello Burger, the Pioneer Burger, and the Cali Burger. All burgers come on a sesame bun with a variety of delicious trimmings, and all are fabulous.

colourful restaurant interior of Allswell in Brooklyn

124 Bedford Avenue, Williamsburg

+1 347 799 2743


2) Diner

For more than twenty years this beautiful 90-year-old Pullman dining car, located on a corner under the Williamsburg Bridge, has been the place to go for excellent food and people-watching. But their amazing burger is the real star of the show. The charming waiters write out the daily menu onto your butcher-paper tablecloth, which is an entertaining touch. After all these years of being a quality hipster place, this place still continues to deliver the same quality of its early days.

dark wooden exterior of Diner restaurant in Brooklyn NYC

Gabriel Flores

85 Broadway, Williamsburg

+1 718 486 3077


More hidden secrets of Brooklyn?

Discover Brooklyn in the footsteps of a local and discover places most tourists won’t go in this uniquely curated neighborhood guide of Brooklyn. Available in our webshop now.

Buy the book or ebook

3) Nathan's Famous

Nathan’s is an institution. The original Coney Island restaurant was founded in 1916 by the Polish immigrant Nathan Handwerker and is still in the same location on the corner of Surf and Stillwell Avenue. It is also home of the annual 4th of July Hot Dog Eating Contest. In 2021, Joey Chestnut set a new world record by eating 76 hot dogs and buns in 10 minutes. Eat that!

corner building with Nathan's Famous restaurant in it on Coney Island

1310 Surf Avenue, Coney Island

+1 718 333 2202


4) Emily

Emily is a small space with tons of character that makes very good thin crust pizza, but it’s the Emily Burger that is the talk of the town. What makes this burger so good? Extremely high-quality meat, cooked medium rare in one big, juicy patty; plenty of melted cheddar cheese; sweet, caramelized onions; a brioche/pretzel bun; and a slightly spicy sauce. There’s also a West Village location in Manhattan.

people enjoying dinner at Emily restaurant in Brooklyn

919 Fulton Street, Clinton Hill

+1 347 844 9588


5) Red Hook Tavern

This beautiful old space pays tribute to the working-class pubs of New York and classic American food on a quiet corner in Red Hook. A line of tables under electric gas lamps and stools with a white-oak bar, combined with the wallpaper and tin ceiling make this place look like real old New York. But the biggest attraction has to be its cheeseburger, which is a damn good New York City pub burger!

beautiful vintage interior of Red Hook Tavern restaurant in Brooklyn

329 Van Brunt Street, Red Hook

+1 917 966 6094


Join the community

Sign up for free to gain unlimited access to the website. Plus, you'll receive a 10% discount in our online bookshop.

Sign up